Monopsony Power

Need help with your homework? Look no further! Our subject experts are ready to effortlessly handle your assignments, so you can finally say goodbye to stress and hello to top grades.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Click or drag files to this area to upload. You can upload up to 3 files.
⚡Get a response in under 15 min

10.6. Monopsony Power

Monopsony power is the buyer’s ability to affect the price of a product. Though pure monopsony is rare, there are some markets where only little numbers of individual firms compete with each otheras buyers. In such markets each buyer enjoys some monopsony power and influence the price of a product.

The best example of monopsony power is the automobile market of the US where the major auto makers are competing among themselves as consumers of tires. Each of them has more or less monopsony power in the tire market. General Motor, the biggest auto maker in the United States, exerts a great monopsony power when selecting a tire manufacturer or the suppliers of other automobile accessories.

Price of a product is equivalent to marginal value in the competitive market. But a market, which is driven by monopsony power of a buyer, goods are often sold at a price lower than marginal value. Price is determined considering the resistance of supply the buyer is facing. In a case of very elastic supply (Es is large), there is not much difference between price valueand marginal value, and the buyer cannot exert high monopsony power. In contrast, if source is very inelastic then price will be much lower than the marginal value and its buyer will exert higher monopsony power on the market.

Determinants of Monopsony Power

There are three factors which determine degree of monopsony power: Elasticity of market supply, number of consumers who are present in the market, along with that the manner those consumers interact among themselves.

Elasticity of Market Supply

Degree of monopsony power depends a lot on elasticity of market supply. If we consider the part of monopsonist, itwill be in profit side. If it faces upward-sloping supply curve which indicates thatmarginal expenditure is more than average expenditure.

If supply curve is less elastic, it results in greater average expenditure and marginal expenditure differentiation that enables the buyers to enjoy higher monopsony power.

Monopsony power of a pure monopsonist totally depends on elasticity of market supply. Higher the elasticity of supply, little the monopoly power is and the sole buyer enjoys a little benefit.

Number of consumers in the market

Degree of monopsony power depends a lot on amount of buyers present in the market. If we consider buyers are more, then a sole buyer cannot exert much force on price. As a result, the supply curve is too elastic and the market turns into a competitive market. A market with limited buyers is highly affected by its monopsony power.

The way of interaction among the consumers

Mpnopsony power is very much dependent on buyers’ approach. For example, if there are 3 or 4 buyers who are competing with each other for a single aggressively and quote a price almost equal to the marginal value of produced product then they will be left with less monopsony power. But if those buyers do not compete aggressively, or even get united, the price will continue to remain less than the marginal value and the degree of monopsony power will be high.

Evaluating the degree of buyers’ monopsony power is not simple because there are so many factors which decides the degree of monopsony power.  Though it is possible to count buyers and estimating elasticity of supply curve, ascertaining the way of interaction among buyers is very difficult.

Impact of monopsony power on the society

Monopsony power is beneficial for the buyer because prices are less than the marginal value but sellers are at losing end. It is important to determine the impact of monopsony power on both buyers and sellers. To evaluate this, we need to compare the presence of buyer plus seller of a competitive market which are driven by monopsony power. For this we should consider average and marginal outflow curves along with marginal value curve. Monopsonist enjoys the maximum net benefit when a quantity (Qm) is purchased at a price (Pm)so that the marginal value is equivalent to marginal expenditure.

Taking the case of competitive market, where price is equivalent to marginal value, the competitive price (Pc) and competitive quantity (Qc) are found when average expenditure intersects with marginal value curves.

With monopsony power, both price and quantity sold are less. Sellers lose a portion of surplus due to the lower price and reduced sales. However, by purchasing at a lower price, the consumer gains in terms of the surplus. In terms of quantity, a buyer purchases lesser than the buyers in competitive market. Overall, monoposony power costs net loss of surplus to the society. Even if a tax is removed from the monopsonist’s gains and then redistributed to producers, it would result in inefficiency, as output value would be lower compared to that of the competitive market.

Bilateral Monopoly

Bilateral monopoly is a term used to define a market which has only one seller and only one consumer. It is very tough to figure out price and quantity in a bipolar market, as both the seller and the buyer are in a position to bargain.

There is no simple way to determine either the seller or the buyer will be the winner in the bargaining  process. That party who have more time, patience and convincing power will be the winner.

Bilateral monopoly is unusual. Usually,  we find some markets where exist a little number of sellers who have gained monopoly power and a limited buyers who some monopsony power.  A rough principle can be applied in such markets to determine the result of bargaining between the sellers and the buyers. Here, both the monopoly power and the monopsony power islikely to offset each other. It can be said that the sellers’ monopoly power will be counter by the buyers’ monopsony power, and vice versa.

A market with bipolar monopoly is also unable to bring perfect competition in the market. It is because if monopoly power affects more the price compared to the monopsony power, the value of residual monopoly power continues to be important.  Generally, monopsony power has the potential to push price more towards the marginal cost, while monopoly power will markdown the price value closer to the marginal value.

10.7 The Antitrust Laws to Limit Market Power

Market power, either monopoly power or monopsony power, is not favourable for economic growth of a country because it has several negative impacts on the society. Market power is a constraint for having potential purchasers to purchase products at competitive rates. Additionally, market power minimizes output, leading to a deadweight loss to the society.

Extreme market power also creates the problems of inequity and unfair practices. If a seller has acquired monopoly power, then he or she would enjoy profit at the cost of consumers. Theoretically, the extra profits of a firm tax away and redistribute among its buyers; however, such redistribution is mostly impractical.  It is not easy to determine the portion of a profit to attribute to monopoly power, and to identify all buyers so that it refunds them according to the ratio of their purchases.

How a society can impose a restriction on market power which prevents it from being used as an anticompetitive? In a case of natural monopoly of electric utility company, considering of direct price guideline is its solution. Effective measures are necessary to restrict the companies from gaining extreme market power that would come fromunions and purchase, and to restrict companies, who have market power.

The governments of the United States and several countries have introduced antitrust laws to limit market power. The antitrust laws include rules and regulations to create a competitive economy by barring actions which could prevent competition in the market. Every country has its own antitrust law.

In the United States and somewhere else, where limitations that include colluding with another company is present, monopoly or market power is not considered as illegal in such places. In contrast, we have noticed patent and copyright laws secure the monopoly status of the companies which developed unique inventions.

For instance, Microsoft has a near-monopoly in developing operating system for personal computers and other software companies are restricted from copying Windows. Microsoft’s monopoly in operating systems cannot be considered as illegal. But if the company exerts monopoly power in the personal computer operating systems to restrict other software companies from launching new operating system for personal computers to reduce competition then it could be illegal.

Restricting the Rights of Firms

When any pharmaceutical company invents new life-saving drug and Apple’s success in inventing the new products iPhone and iPad, it results in economic growth and enhancement of consumer welfare. The antitrust law is required to prevent the companies from enjoying market power through the process which are not so laudable. The antitrust laws work are discussed in the below section at fundamental level.

The Sherman Act (passed in 1890) in its section 1 bans contracts or conspiracies to bring trade under control. An example of illegal combination is- we can consider an open agreement among companies to do production in limited amount or to fix a price more than the competitive price. There has been multiple numbers of instances where we can see practice of illegal combinations and conspiracies.

Hidden collusion of parallel conduct is also against the law. For instance, if Firm X continuously follows Firm Y’s pricing, and if Firm X’s activity is different from that which was expected from the two companies in absence of collusion, a hidden collusion may be inferred.

The Sherman Act in its section 2 has termed monopolizing or intention to control a market as illegal practice. It also prohibits conspiracies which lead to monopolization.

The Clayton Act (1914) has pinpointed the types of practices which could be anticompetitive.  For instance, the act said that it is unlawful if a company needs buyers who do not buy goods from a competitor. The act also considers it illegal to get in involved in predatory pricing. Predatory pricing is the pricing which is designed to drive existing competitors out of the business and to stop new entrants. This is because the predatory company could continue and enjoy greatervalues in the future.

A firm can gain monopoly power by merging with larger firms, or by acquiring a firm or by taking controller of another firm which has potential to create a monopoly.

The amended Clayton Act (1936) states that discriminating among buyers by charging different prices from different buyers for the same product to prevent competition is illegal.  Even the firms try to justify that the price differences are necessary to meet the competition, it is an illegal practice.

Supplementing the Sherman and Clayton acts in the market concerns, the Federal Trade Commission Act fosters competition through a complete set of barring against anticompetitive and unfair practices, which include deceptive advertisement and branding, agreements with retailers so that they could exclude opposing brands, and many more. The FTC Act offers extensive powers compared to other acts, as the aforesaid prohibitions are explained and put into practice in organizational proceedings prior to the FTC.

Actually, the antitrust laws are phrased vaguely considering what is allowed and not allowed.  The antitrust laws aim to provide general statutory framework so that it offers the Justice Department of the FTC and the courts extended justification to interpret and apply them. It is an important approach, as it is difficult to determine the obstruction to competition beforehand.  Such vagueness generates the necessity for general law and alternate provisions and rulings.

Implementation of the Antitrust Laws in the US

In the US the antitrust laws are implemented in three ways:

1.      Through Antitrust Division of Department of Justice

Theimplement of its policies according to the outlook of the administration is in power. The department can begin a criminal proceeding or bring a civil suit, or take both the actions in response to the external complaint. The criminal actions different for corporation and individuals.  The corporations can slapped be with penalties, while individuals can be either slapped with penalties or sentenced imprisonment. For example, if the antitrust department finds individuals are engaged in conspiracy to fix prices or rigging bids then those can be charged and the culprits may be sentenced to imprisonment. It is noteworthy that if you have an intention to parlay your understanding of microeconomics then the business career would be successful! Losing a civil proceeding compels a corporation to stop its anticompetitive practices and sometime to pay damages.

2.      Through administrative procedures of Federal Trade Commission

In response to an external compliant or from the FTC’s own initiative actions are taken against those who promote anticompetitive or unfair market practices. Before deciding which action is to be taken against those who are found guilty, FTC can seek a voluntary considerate to abide by the law or request formal command order for requiring compliance.

3.      Through the private proceedings

Individuals and firms can take a party to the court for causing treble damages to their business or property. Individuals or firms can also request the courts to impose ban against the wrongdoers for restraining anticompetitive actions.

The antitrust laws of the United States are more severe and far reaching compared to those of other countries. In reality, some people have justified that they have restrained American industry effectively in global markets. The laws surely prevent American business and at some point of time have taken American companies at a difficult position in the international markets.

However, the negative aspects of the United States’ antitrust laws are overshadowed by their benefits: The antitrust laws have been vital to keep the market competitive, and competition is necessary for economic efficiency, modernization and development.

Antitrust Laws in Europe

With the development of European Union, it has also developed the method of implementing antitrust laws. The responsibility for implementing the antitrust concerns which comprises of more than two member states is available, the Brussels-based Competition Directorate. Each member state has separate, distinct and antitrust authorities who are responsible for these types of concerns whose consequences are felt greatly or entirely within specific countries.

There are lots of similarities between the antitrust laws of European Union and United States. However, lots of substantive and procedural variations also exist between the antitrust laws in the European Union and United States. In Europe, merger evaluations usually are carried out promptly and it is simpler to establish that a Europe-based company is dominant, while in the United States it is quite tough to prove the monopoly power of a company.

Though European Union and United States have been actively implementing laws against the value of price fixing, in Europe just civil penalties are imposed and in the United States both imprisonment and financial penalties are imposed.

Over the last ten years, implementation of antitrust laws has increased rapidly across the world. At present, in more than one hundred countries there exist active enforcement agencies for this purpose. There is no formal global antitrust enforcement body but the International Competition Network sponsors a meeting at least once in a year where all the enforcement agencies meet together.

 

Links of Previous Main Topic:-

Links of Next Microeconomics Topics:-

Homework Blues?

Get expert help with homework for all subjects.

  • NPlagiarism-free work
  • NHonest Pricing
  • NMoney-back guarantee

Latest Reviews

Solved Sample Works

Accounting Homework

Corporate Accounting Sample

Biology Homework

Genetics Assignment Sample

Essay Writing Help

Business Plan Sample

Homework Help FAQs

Our Answers to Your Questions

How do I submit my homework?
K
L

Getting homework help is very simple with us. Students can either send us the homework via email or they can upload it to our online form here. For a quicker response, You can also chat with us at WhatsApp and submit homework directly. You are sure to get a response from our side within 10 minutes.

How much will my homework cost?
K
L

The cost of paying someone to do your homework varies depending on the service and the type of assignment. We have listed our standard pricing plans for popularly used writing services. For other kind of assignments, You can get a free instant quote from us using our online form.

We also accept partial payment to start working on your assignment help. You can pay the remaining amount when your task gets completed. No pressure of up-front payment. No hidden order costs.

Can I receive help with my homework anytime?
K
L

Yes, you can receive help with your homework anytime with us. Our online homework help services are available 24/7, allowing you to receive assistance with your homework anytime, anywhere.

For urgent homework requests, reach out to us through our LiveChat or WhatsApp channels and one of our friendly support agents will assist you in finding the right expert for your online homework help request immediately. With our services, you can rely on 24/7 availability and meeting deadlines.

Are online homework websites budget-friendly for students like me?
K
L

Yes, Our Online Homework Help websites are an affordable solution for you as a student. Compared to traditional tutoring services, MyHomeworkHelp prices their homework help services honestly and within the budget of college students. This makes it easier for you to receive assistance with your homework without breaking the bank.

What is your plagiarism-free policy?
K
L

At myhomeworkhelp, we take plagiarism very seriously and ensure that all solutions provided by our tutors are original and authentic. Our tutors are trained to provide custom-made solutions, tailored specifically to meet the requirements of each student. We do not provide pre-written papers. All our homeswork solutions are made from scratch, guaranteeing 100% orignal homework answers.

Additionally, we have strict plagiarism-detection tools in place to check all submissions for authenticity.

Is using an Online Homework Help Service cheating?
K
L

Using online homework help services is not equivalent to cheating. Our services are intended to support students with their homework and provide them with the resources they need to succeed academically. With the help of our online homework help services, students can receive immediate assistance with their homework from any location, at any time.

At myhomeworkhelp, we are committed to promoting academic integrity. Our tutors provide solutions that serve as guides for drafting your own work. It is not acceptable to submit someone else's work as your own, as this constitutes academic plagiarism.

Can I chat with my tutor?
K
L

Using our secure chat board, you can now chat directly with your assigned tutor. The chats are encrypted both ways to secure your privacy. This makes your contact with the tutor directly & confidentially, so you can better explain any requirements or changes if needed or just need updates.

You can't contact the experts outside of chat board platform. Sharing any personal information, including but not limited to contact information, goes against our Terms and Conditions and therefore may result in permanently blocking you from the platform. We take any personal data very seriously and we do it for the safety of our users.

Know more about chat board here.

What is your money-back guarantee policy?
K
L

It’s worth noting that our online homework help service rarely leads to disappointment among students. Our expert tutors, along with our support and quality assurance team, are dedicated to providing the best possible experience for our customers. However, if for any reason a student is unsatisfied with their homework help solution, we offer unlimited revisions until they are fully satisfied.

In the rare event that a student remains unsatisfied even after revisions, we offer a money-back guarantee. We want all of our students to feel confident and secure when they turn to us for assistance with their homework, and this guarantee is just one way that we demonstrate our commitment to providing the best possible service. If you have any concerns about our services or the quality of the work you receive, please contact us for support.

What is the expertise of the tutor assigned to do my homework?
K
L

At myhomeworkhelp, we take pride in our team of qualified and experienced tutors. All of our tutors undergo a rigorous selection process and are required to have a minimum of a master's degree in their respective fields. Additionally, they must pass a series of tests to demonstrate their proficiency and ability to deliver quality work. We believe in transparency and providing our clients with the best possible service. You can be confident in the expertise of the tutor assigned to do your homework.

What about privacy & confidentiality?
K
L

Using My Homework Help is absolutely safe. We care about your security, therefore we encrypt all personal data to make every user feel safe while using our services and we don’t share any personal information with any third parties without your permission. Your credit card information is not stored anywhere at My Homework Help, and use of PayPal relies on their secure payment networks. Your identity, payment and homework are in safe hands. You can always be certain of getting professional help and remaining anonymous, while using My Homework Help.